A triumph in Aix-en-Provence
Natalie Dessay's first European Violetta reviewed
Readers of yesterday's blog will know that Aix festival director Bernard Foccroulle spoke of the event being about making connections between art forms, as between the past and the present. All of which was clearly in evidence in the stunning production of Verdi's La Traviata that I witnessed last night.
Yesterday morning a visit to the local Musée Granee here had yielded an insight into the vision of the great art collector Jean Planque – who had come to realise how, with some artists, one shouldn't look too specifically at the details or even think too literally. One should instead find the music in the textures. So it was with Jean-Francois Sivadier's staging of the Verdi.
A play-wthin-a-play framing might sound old hat, but we were in the dangerous world of Pirandello here, where staged action can suddenly become real for the performers and the edge between fiction and truth is knife edge-thin. So there were stage managers and lots of arranging of sets and so on. But there were broad subtexts (for some a dread word, I know, but it worked). The stage positions, the backdrops, these seemed all to be about public image – very effective for instance in the sunny blue-sky cloths that hung above Alfredo's house in the second act, or when in the first Violetta suddenly broke free of her "scene" and marched to the "backstage" tables at the rear of the stage to down almost half a bottle of vodka. At her death, the company watched from the side, shocked yet rooted to the spot.
For Natalie Dessay's Violetta, I can only say that I doubt there has ever been a singer in this role (even Callas, whom I never saw) who was more shattering. She moved with an animal abandon yet a desperation for physical contact, whether rolling her head along Alfredo's arm or forcing herself into his father's embrace. Then, at the end, her energy totally left her as her Marilyn Monroe wig and stage make-up were removed for her and she was left, with barely the will to shake her head at a glass of water, spent. That her light, supple voice is not really one of nature's Violettas is in this rare case wholly irrelevant. She made it work.
Alongside her, Charles Castronovo was an ardent Alfredo, Ludovic Tézier a too young-looking but authoritive-sounding Germont. There was an attention-grabbing voice among the smaller roles too, in Andrea Mastroni's Marchese. Watch out for him.
As in the previous night's show, the London Symphony Orchestra were on top form, blending exquisite detail with true operatic punch. Their conductor Louis Langrée, in apparently his first Verdi opera, found darkness in the score without sacrificing elegance. A magnificent evening. Oh, and there's a good chance Virgin Classics will issue it on DVD, so watch this space.
James Inverne is former editor of Gramophone. He now runs a music management + PR company, Inverne Price Music Consultancy, writes a culture column for the Jewish Chronicle newspaper and his byline can still be found from time to time in other places about subjects that get him exercised.


Comments
One is very tempted to compare performances
of great singers. My first question was going to be which Violetta out of the
past am I going to use as standard? I
feel that last night’s performance has set a new standard. Am I glad that James
Inverne dared to compare as well.
One of the great successes and memorable
occasions of the past 20 years was Angela Gheorghiu’s Violetta at Covent Garden
under Sir Georg Solti in 1994. It was
Angela’s sensational debut. The BBC/Decca registration of that has had a
prominent place on my shelf.
Last night’s European debut of Natalie
Dessay’s role as Violetta was as sensational if not overwhelming and more
moving. Stunning it certainly was. The
LSO’s playing could not have been better.
This was for me a rare occasion to compare two formidable orchestra’s. LSO’s string players just gave that extra
needed edge and articulation over Convent Garden’s orchestra. Interesting as the LSO is not a typical opera
orchestra.
The TV direction and sound direction were
absolutely superb. I managed to
re-assemble my original set-up of amplifier and TDL Reference Standard
loudspeakers. Although not in full
surround mode, the broadcast still gave me the sense of being at the opera. I
noticed that with performances like this the old fashioned standard stereo
set-up works. The projection of the sound at an opera like this is from the
stage into the auditorium. What else does one need? There were enough Violettas
in the audience to compete with Violetta on stage . I didn’t need more
reference to them.
The BBC/Decca’s registration at Covent
Garden has a little less stage noise than this recording at Aix. Violetta had at some points a brush with her
microphone. I found the sound projection
at Aix, despite these little hick-ups more real.
The stage backdrops worked very well on TV
too, especially when Alfredo and Violetta are snuggled up in a field. It looked most realistic. It would certainly work at a screening in a
cinema.
Once the DVD is published it will get an as
prominent place if not more than Decca/ROHCG’s version.
I agree that it was a theatrically charged performance from Natalie Dessay. I think she is an incredible stage animal and shows an unwavering vulnerability throughout La traviata.
I can't help but wonder if Jean-Francois Sivadier's La traviata was produced around her, and if Dessay would be able to pull off the same trick vocally in a production that was void of theatre. The vulnerability in her voice was too genuine and I fear that the trend of untouchable opera stars turning their hand to any opera they choose and getting undeserved praise for it is very tiring. Not to mention extremely unhealthy.
Intereseting. I would like to see/hear Natalie at one of the big opera houses e.g. ROHCG in say Lucia di Lammermoor or Anna Bolena. Still lets enjoy her whilst it lasts.
It certainly sounds like the play-within-a-play production Dessay had @ The MET when they did a new LA SONNAMBULA with her a season back. These concept productions let Dessay play 'on' the role rather than actually 'play' the role.
er . . . discuss