I am missing a lot of exceptional performers in the shortlists of the Hall off fame:
Eliahu inbal (Mahler 2,3,5,7 unsurpassed!)
Sergiu Celibadache (Bruckner - different but pearls for your collection)
Myung Whun Chung (Prokofiev - Romeo and Juliet , is there an alternative?)
Hillary Hahn (Barber - violinconcerto, Vaughan Williams - Lark ascending)
Kent Nagano (Strawinsky - Sacre , no better recording ever so)
Maybe there are more I did not think of yet. And You who do you think should be in the Hall of fame who is not included in the lists?