Hall of Fame

37 replies [Last post]
ladroldedame
ladroldedame's picture
Offline
Joined: 24th Jan 2012
Posts: 11
RE: Hall of Fame

Of course I know and I like Bartoli (she is the first mezzo in whom I was interested) and Garanca. Bartoli is incredible in baroque repertoire, I envy her agility, and I like the warm of Garanca's voice. 

I don't know if I could one day sing a role but I love Rosina, Susanna, Isabella,... for their strength, their fight for freedom and love. In fact, I particularly like Rossini and Mozart

But for the moment, my voice is changing, I'm originally a soprano but I develop more and more my medium and low range. I don't know if I'm becoming a mezzo, so I continue to discover my voice. It's thrilling!

Thank you very much for your advice and your kindness. I had another experience with a forum on classical music, and it was not as pleasant as here. It was impossible to have an opinion if it wasn't the same as the others! 

Tous mes voeux !

 

parla
parla's picture
Online
Joined: 6th Aug 2011
Posts: 2093
RE: Hall of Fame

I suspected that you should be a former soprano becoming a mezzo. So, my next question is do you envisage yourself as  a possible Coloratura mezzo or a lyric one? Di Donato, Bartoli, Garanca, Horne (this is beyond categories, I guess) and my most beloved Berganza belonged mostly to Coloratura.

However, if you wish to sing certain roles of Mozart, like Annio, Cherubino, Dorabella, Idamante or Sesto, you need also to follow some a bit "rounder"  voices, like Janet Baker, Brigitte Fassbaender, my favourite Anne Sofie von Otter, my beloved Frederica von Stade and the late and so great Tatiana Troyanos. From the modern ones, I guess the best example is Susan Graham.

By the way, which is your actual vocal range (G below middle C to high B natural or you can reach the high C as well)?

Meilleurs voeux a vous aussi.

Parla

kev
kev's picture
Offline
Joined: 23rd Sep 2010
Posts: 203
RE: Hall of Fame RE: Hall of Fame

Tsaraslondon1 wrote:

...some reason her undoubted stage personaliy doesn't seem to come across on disc, and for that reason, I'm not sure I could include her in a Gramophone Hall of Fame.

Do you have some sort of 'ticks all the boxes' checklist Tsaraslondon1?  I was thinking of voting for one living singer and one deceased but that's as far as my plan goes so far.  When you stop to think of the number of the possible criteria, it's quite a daunting task (especially as I'm not a connoisseur (yet)).

__________________

'After silence, that which comes nearest to expressing the inexpressible is music'.  
Aldous Huxley  brainyquote.com

ladroldedame
ladroldedame's picture
Offline
Joined: 24th Jan 2012
Posts: 11
RE: Hall of Fame

I think I've not the "roundness" of mezzo voices but my medium begins to be richer of colours. I can reach high C but I don't know where is exactly my low range, I'm working on it (en français, ma tessiture s'étend environ du mi grave au contre-mi, I'm not familiar with the english range's system). If I become a mezzo, I think it will be a mezzo coloratura. 

I'm going to follow your suggestions. 

Ladroldedame

Tsaraslondon1
Tsaraslondon1's picture
Offline
Joined: 11th Jan 2011
Posts: 23
RE: Hall of Fame RE: Hall of Fame

kev wrote:

 

Do you have some sort of 'ticks all the boxes' checklist Tsaraslondon1?  I was thinking of voting for one living singer and one deceased but that's as far as my plan goes so far.  When you stop to think of the number of the possible criteria, it's quite a daunting task (especially as I'm not a connoisseur (yet)).

No I don't really have a check list, but I went for those singers who speak to me via the medium of recorded sound. My list of course personal, as I would expect everyone else's to be. All the singers I chose have distinctive voices, recognisable from only a few notes, Callas being the obvious example. But, though the voice is instantly recognisable, by some strange alchemy, she can sound utterly different from one role to the next. When someone once said to the late, much missed John Steane, that "Of course you had to see her," he replied, "Oh, but I can, and I do." I know exactly what he means.

.

 

parla
parla's picture
Online
Joined: 6th Aug 2011
Posts: 2093
RE: Hall of Fame

Votre tessiture est formidable, Ladroldedame. Definitevement, vous pouvez devenir a Mezzo Coloratura.

All the best. With this tessitura you can easily move to soprano roles as well. I guess Rosina (from Rossini's Barbiere) or La Cenerentola or L'Italiana would be perfect for you. Study Horne and Berganza predominantly.

Tous mes voeux pour une carriere brilliante.

Parla

ladroldedame
ladroldedame's picture
Offline
Joined: 24th Jan 2012
Posts: 11
RE: Hall of Fame

Thanks! I don't know yet if I can and if I want to have a career. I work seriously on my voice since only 5 years and I'm in a conservatory since only one year. But we don't know what the future is made of!^^

A bientôt!

Ladroldedame

 

Atonal
Atonal's picture
Offline
Joined: 3rd Oct 2011
Posts: 169
RE: Hall of Fame

JKH wrote:
Ding dong? Terry-Thomas? Lesley Phillis, surely! You're an absolute shaaawer, Atonal.

Getting my bounders/cads mixed up. 

__________________

Pause for thought.

JKH
JKH's picture
Offline
Joined: 28th Jul 2010
Posts: 457
RE: Hall of Fame

Atonal wrote:

JKH wrote:
Ding dong? Terry-Thomas? Lesley Phillis, surely! You're an absolute shaaawer, Atonal.

Getting my bounders/cads mixed up. 

I bet LP would be a tad upset about my mistyping his name. Oooh, matron!

__________________

JKH

Peter Street
Peter Street's picture
Offline
Joined: 22nd Sep 2010
Posts: 63
RE: Hall of Fame

I would like to have been offered the chance to vote for Rudolf Serkin, who doesn't seem to have been included as a soloist. or as an ensemble player.    Adolf Busch, with whom he played as a duo, isn't allowed in as a soloist either, but we do have the chance to vote for the Busch Quartet.  In fact, Serkin's most enduring contribution to the Gramophone arguably grew out of his collaboration with them, but Gramophone's categories have somehow managed to squeeze him out of any recognition in the first round and it's difficult to see how he can now fit in.   Not very sensible editing.

__________________

Peter Street

patshaw
patshaw's picture
Offline
Joined: 23rd Nov 2010
Posts: 1
RE: Hall of Fame

Must admit Dame Janet Baker surely has to be allowed to walk straight into the Hall of Fame. Sensible, sensitive, beautiful,extremely intelligent about how she might best maximize her God - given voice without burning out - her instantly recognizable voice will bear ANYONE up in times of sadness!

Ditto - Mirella Freni, Elizabeth Harwood ~ one could go on but one does not want to overbore!

__________________
Jay Ashby
Jay Ashby's picture
Offline
Joined: 8th Feb 2012
Posts: 1
RE: Hall of Fame

I realise that it is impossible for every singer of note to be included in the Hall of Fame, but I must say I am very surprised at the omission of Giacomo Aragall from the Tenor list.

HeidelbergSoprano
HeidelbergSoprano's picture
Offline
Joined: 24th Jan 2012
Posts: 3
RE: Hall of Fame

In no way would Netrebko surpress La Divina that is certain - I meant her status as the leading soprano. She has many fans that appreciate her singing and acting that leads to packing opera houses, movie theaters (Met Opera HD presentations, etc.), recital halls, concert halls, and many other places! 

__________________

HeidelbergSoprano

josé echenique
josé echenique's picture
Offline
Joined: 2nd Apr 2011
Posts: 8
RE: Hall of Fame

I totally agree. It´s unbelievable that Janet Baker and Cecilia Bartoli made the Hall of Fame and the GREAT Teresa Berganza didn´t. It´s a scandal, as is the inclusion of Rattle and the omission of Bruno Walter, Fritz Reiner, Victor de Sabata, Carlo Maria Giulini, Ferenc Fricsay, Rafael Kubelik, etc.

How old are the people that made the list? 10? 

__________________

José Echenique

RUREF
RUREF's picture
Offline
Joined: 25th Nov 2010
Posts: 35
RE: Hall of Fame RE: Hall of Fame

A new contributor, ladroldedame - Welcome!

I note from another post from you on this topic you say you didn't grow up with the 'old school' singers. Never mind - there's a whole world of vocal thrills awaiting you.

When you have a moment (or six!) have a listen to some of them - Janet Baker in Handel, Barbara Bonney in Mozart & Schubert, Jessye Norman singing Strauss Four Last Songs!

Such a wealth of glorious music.

Have fun and enjoy!

__________________

Ruref