Software to catalogue classical music collection

53 replies [Last post]
Scoastlistener
Scoastlistener's picture
Offline
Joined: 2nd Apr 2010
Posts: 26

Does anyone have a recommendation for software to catalogue a CD collection?  I have looked extensively and have settled on Music Collector, which is very slow and unwieldy, and doesn't work well for multiple works and/or composers on the same disc.  Has anyone had better success please?  I am using a windows pc.

computermike
computermike's picture
Offline
Joined: 30th Mar 2010
Posts: 4
RE: Software to catalogue classical music collection

My answer is yes, but...

I have been writing some general purpose catalogue software over many years; it is opensource at http://sourceforge.net/projects/openjean/ . While general purpose one of the reasons I started it was to handle my own CD collection. The "but" bit is that it is still in an early stage and though it does work and I use it all the time, it is probably not for the faint heated; the interface is fairly "clunky" and performance is not great.

I am working on a much improved version, which includes better facilities for playing the music including streaming from a server, and the music (or multimedia) catalogue can be run as a separate application. Performance and ease of use will also be much better. Unfortunately, since I have to work for a living and I like to spend time with my family and actually listening to music, I do not get all that much chance to work on it so I doubt if the new version will be ready before the summer.

 

(computer)mike

richardf333
richardf333's picture
Offline
Joined: 31st Mar 2010
Posts: 3
RE: Software to catalogue classical music collection

  This is a very timely question.  There are some very expensive high end music servers out there (Q-Logic and others) that are just glorified Hard Drives with a software package that makes the users music easy to access.

   Some of these gizmos cost up to 15K U.S. 

   Anyone with a Mac or PC can do most of what this provides, but we need better software packages than something like itunes for Classical Music.

   I'd be willing to pay a few hundred dollars for a program if it worked well.

yelob
yelob's picture
Offline
Joined: 15th Dec 2009
Posts: 9
RE: Software to catalogue classical music collection

You can rip all your CD's to Itunes which automatically creates a list,including individual movements but this is very slow.

Garbolinski
Garbolinski's picture
Offline
Joined: 20th Dec 2009
Posts: 40
RE: Software to catalogue classical music collection

Try Collectorz.com not ideal but pretty good.  Their systems will also work for DVD's and books.

jdk
jdk's picture
Offline
Joined: 8th May 2010
Posts: 21
RE: Software to catalogue classical music collection

The good thing about the Collectorz software is that you can scan barcodes to automate input. I haven't tried this for my CD collection yet, but I did use their DVD software to catalogue my collection, and it made it very easy. I bought a scanner from Collectorz that could hold 500 barcodes in its memory at a time. You spend an hour scanning your DVDs, then attach the scanner to your computer, and the Collectorz software automatically imports the barcodes and consults its database.

So long as the barcode is in the database (and for DVDs, the vast majority of my collection was in their database), then you don't have to type in any data -- the software does it for you.

John_Connor
John_Connor's picture
Offline
Joined: 27th Jul 2010
Posts: 1
RE: Software to catalogue classical music collection

In my experience, OrangeCD Catalog by Firetongue Software has been extremely user-friendly as well as reliable. It comes with a fully functional 30-day trial too so that you can test drive it before making a financial commitment.

I also wanted to "chime" in here and let everyone know that I recently found a very good source for piano sheet music called Piano Street. Their blog is regularly updated and a fairly interesting resource for those that aren't already active participants.

Garbolinski
Garbolinski's picture
Offline
Joined: 20th Dec 2009
Posts: 40
RE: Software to catalogue classical music collection

Do try Collectorz.com - I catalogued all my compact discs in two days - a friend lent me his bar code reader - about 2,300 went in and were nicely catalogued.  A few glitches but that was to be expected.  I also did my DVD's.  There is a trial version you can use for 30 days to see if you like it.  Personally I though the c. £29.00 very well spent and there are regular updates for the software.  If I have ever had a problem I just send them an e-mail and have a response the same day - they are always so very helpful.  There are many bar code scanners available at a discount just check the internet. I am very happy to reccommendt his software.  Happy filing!  Robert.

David W Hutchins
David W Hutchins's picture
Offline
Joined: 9th Oct 2010
Posts: 1
RE: Software to catalogue classical music collection

I recommend Classic Collector 2000. I have been using it for several years and love it. It is very complete and versatile. It is available for free from http://web.onetel.com/~lionelkremer/CC.htm Unfortunately, as I just discovered when I bought a new computer, it is not compatible with Windows 7. The developer is unable, due to poor health to update it. It would be great if some developer would purchase the program to update it for Windows 7. If anyone does, please let me know. I hate to think of starting all over to catalog my many cds. If you are not running 7 (it works for XP and Vista) I think you would find it very satisfactory.

UPDATE: It works on the 32bit version of Windows 7. Hoorah!!!

__________________

davyc82601

JRosenfeld
JRosenfeld's picture
Offline
Joined: 29th Mar 2010
Posts: 5
RE: Software to catalogue classical music collection

I have created my catalogue in an Excel file. This has allowed me to have the column headings I want (including comments), and the ability to search, sort, etc. intrinsic to Excel. It currently contains 2,781 records, and counting...

Bartleby
Bartleby's picture
Offline
Joined: 21st Oct 2010
Posts: 11
RE: Software to catalogue classical music collection

It's simple.  Get a Mac.  Then get Delicious 2.

__________________

Bartleby

Petra01
Petra01's picture
Offline
Joined: 16th Mar 2010
Posts: 272
RE: Software to catalogue classical music collection

JRosenfeld wrote:

I have created my catalogue in an Excel file. This has allowed me to have the column headings I want (including comments), and the ability to search, sort, etc. intrinsic to Excel. It currently contains 2,781 records, and counting...

Hello.  I've been toying with the idea of making my own (haven't played around in Excel in ages though!) after trying iTunes which seems to me to be too limiting...I would like them to have more data fields.  Would you be willing to share some tips/tricks that you've learned after fighting your way through creating this system?  What fields do you use?  Any stumbling blocks?

Thank you and happy listening!

Best wishes,

Petra

 

p.s.  What programs/systems do you fine folks at Gramophone use for your personal use?  And/or do some of you rely strickly on memory? :)  Warm wishes, P.

 

haakan7
haakan7's picture
Offline
Joined: 4th Jan 2010
Posts: 1
RE: Software to catalogue classical music collection

   I have tried many organizers and finally ended with CATraxx. Simply perfect compared to Music Collector. Very powerfull search machine, friendly interface , you won't regrett.

Petra01
Petra01's picture
Offline
Joined: 16th Mar 2010
Posts: 272
RE: Software to catalogue classical music collection

haakan7 wrote:

   I have tried many organizers and finally ended with CATraxx. Simply perfect compared to Music Collector. Very powerfull search machine, friendly interface , you won't regrett.

haakan7,

Thanks for mentioning it.  I'll check it out. :)

Best wishes,

Petra

 

kengee
kengee's picture
Offline
Joined: 20th May 2010
Posts: 1
RE: Software to catalogue classical music collection

I have used a program called Classicat v2.1 for over ten years with 3758 different recordings, mostly classical LP's, in the database. I bought a new computer, but the backup disc I bought with the program doesn't work and the developer/website are out of business. Can anyone help with a copy of the program? Alternatively, although I am not enamored of the various programs mentioned that I have looked at, which of them would enable me to import my database, if anyone knows. Finally, is anyone familiar with Maestro Manager? It looks like it might be suitable, but I received no response to email asking for demo version. Many thanks for any assistance provided

__________________

K G Longo

JRosenfeld
JRosenfeld's picture
Offline
Joined: 29th Mar 2010
Posts: 5
RE: Software to catalogue classical music collection

Sorry for late response, I've not been back to the forum for a while.

Note I use Office pro XP, but I'm sure the same is possible with later versions of Excel.

My Excel sheet has the following columns (A to I):
Composer
Title
Opus
Label
Number
Ensemble
Conductor
Soloists
Remarks
Of course one can have others, to taste (for example you might want to add a column for date of recording, or for your rating).

The sheet is organised as follows:

The top row has the colmn headings, followed by a blank row. These two rows define the criteria range ($A$1:$I$2 in my case) used for the advanced filtering function of Excel ((Data/filter/advanced).

The table proper starts below these, with the column headings in the third row, then each entry in its own row.

So the list range in the advanced filter goes from $A$3:$I$xxx where xxx is the last filled row in the table (which Excel fills in automatically)

To filter the rows in the table, for example in which a particular conductor appears, copy or type the name of that conductor into the second row under the conductor column, then use the advanced filter. Similarly, if you want to find all the entries in which a particular soloist appears, type the name in the second row under the soloists column. Remember to clear contents in the second row when you revert to the full table. (data/filter/show all).

For convenience I have sorted the table by 1. Composer, 2. Opus number, 3. Title (in case the Opus number is blank) but of course that is also a matter of taste.

I hope that helps.