The worst record covers ever

211 replies [Last post]
Atonal
Atonal's picture
Offline
Joined: 3rd Oct 2011
Posts: 165
RE: The worst record covers ever

I just don't get Naxos' policy for album covers. Most are naff designs ...

Adams - Violin Concerto

Then the same artist gets this....

 Violin Concertos

nice....

or this....

 Violin Concerto 2, Concerto Romantique, Scenes Poetiques

naff again.

Bizarre! No need for rubbish design when it takes just as much effort to do something almost well.

__________________

Pause for thought.

Atonal
Atonal's picture
Offline
Joined: 3rd Oct 2011
Posts: 165
RE: The worst record covers ever

Anyway .....'tis the music we're wanting most of all, but if we hark back to LP years how we all can just immediately vision our favourite recordings by the LP cover. 

Happy days. 

P.S. Saw Mahler 9, Karajan, BPO on vinyl box set in a cafe record shop in Manchester this weekend.....£2.00! Wish I'd kept my turntable. 

 

__________________

Pause for thought.

Ken Jones
Ken Jones's picture
Offline
Joined: 2nd Feb 2012
Posts: 1
RE: The worst record covers ever

Before DG got rid of their distinctive yellow banner virtually every cover was a winner - some are absolute classics.  I no longer play vinyl but I have a good number of their LPs stashed away - just for occasionaly browsing through, like you would an art book.

These days, though, I'd say around 90% of their covers are nondescript and the rest are stinkers.  The exception to this would be their 20/21 series: every one of these is a winner, the Boulez discs being truly exceptional.

Jamyma
Jamyma's picture
Offline
Joined: 3rd Feb 2012
Posts: 2
RE: The worst record covers ever

Yes, the Mozart-Overtures-Alessandrini album cover was pretty appalling. Some of the Ronald Brautigam-Beethoven- Piano Sonatas covers on Bis (Pictures of Beethoven Strasse etc on a notepad!). Equally ingratiating (and rather boring) are these endless covers of new found violinists generally pictured clutching their violin with head thrust back and hair blowing in the wind. Come on!

The company with the worst album covers must surely be CPO with their abstract art, either organic or kandinsky-like. Example: the JC Bach covers of orchestral works, overtures an concertos conducted by Anthony Halstead. Good God, what is that stuff meant to be? And as for their turgid colours!

I'm also interested in the psychology of what makes people pick up one disc versus another when browsing the shelves?

I'd also like to know whether other readers will avoid a certain album if its cover is too ghastly? I confess I have. As an artist it is a matter of principle to not want to be confronted by really bad art-design everytime you put the disc. A case very much of judging a CD by its cover! ;-)

Jamyma
Jamyma's picture
Offline
Joined: 3rd Feb 2012
Posts: 2
RE: The worst record covers ever
parla
parla's picture
Offline
Joined: 6th Aug 2011
Posts: 1815
RE: The worst record covers ever

Much ado about nothing! Do you judge a book by its cover? So, what's the big deal of whatever might be the cover of a CD?

I have experienced great pain with some very artistic and well designed CDs with poor musical performances. However, on the other, I have tolerated easily some ugly, kitschy covers because of some superb performances.

Therefore, stick to the music, which is the only one that matters. The rest is...(all kind of) noise!..And nonsense (a sort of).

Parla

 

Atonal
Atonal's picture
Offline
Joined: 3rd Oct 2011
Posts: 165
RE: The worst record covers ever

Parla wrote:
Therefore, stick to the music, which is the only one that matters. The rest is...(all kind of) noise!..And nonsense (a sort of).

With respect Parla. YOU stick to the music if you so wish and we'll discuss what the hell we like!

Regards

__________________

Pause for thought.

frostwalrus
frostwalrus's picture
Offline
Joined: 24th Jul 2010
Posts: 78
RE: The worst record covers ever

Parla "Much ado about nothing! Do you judge a book by its cover? So, what's the big deal of whatever might be the cover of a CD?"

Come on, Parla, its just for fun. Nobody is actually judging the music by its cover, but rather we are simply judging the cover. And its just for fun - not to be taken seriously [well, atleast I don't take it seriously] There have been many cases where I praised the recorded music on a CD, but then laughed at the CD cover.

__________________

frostwalrus

Micos69
Micos69's picture
Offline
Joined: 30th Mar 2010
Posts: 109
RE: The worst record covers ever

This is a pity: after years of producing tasteful covers (usually classical landscapes which have some affinity with the recorded music) in these discs Naxos have decided to follow the line of EMI and others, cashing in on the photogenic qualities of the artists to sell their product.

JAH
JAH's picture
Offline
Joined: 6th Feb 2012
Posts: 48
RE: The worst record covers ever

What is the criteria for judging this?

Is it bad artwork? If so, then who else could judge but an artist?

Is it the ability of a cover to evoke an emotion? anger, repulsion, amusement? Who could judge? What scares one person, might amuse another.

Is it sheer dullness?

Is it inappropriateness?

I have looked through a fair number of the suggestions. My nomination is the Vladislav Kazevin cover. In my opinion it would fail any test; it is simply bad, bad, bad. If I had this cd because I liked the music, I would turn over the cover. Now ... what is on the back?

By the way, I rather like the urinating gazelle, and the Pfitzner cover is an ace.  

TedR
TedR's picture
Offline
Joined: 23rd Apr 2010
Posts: 104
RE: The worst record covers ever

I guess in some way it has to make you smile. For instance I bought this lp in Oxfam this weekend:

http://www.recordsale.de/cdpix/d/dvorak-the_water_goblin._noon_witch._husitska.._czech.jpg

Ted

tagalie
tagalie's picture
Offline
Joined: 29th Mar 2010
Posts: 716
RE: The worst record covers ever

TedR wrote:

I guess in some way it has to make you smile. For instance I bought this lp in Oxfam this weekend:

http://www.recordsale.de/cdpix/d/dvorak-the_water_goblin._noon_witch._husitska.._czech.jpg

Ted

Looks rather like Ancerl himself, the morning after.

JAH
JAH's picture
Offline
Joined: 6th Feb 2012
Posts: 48
RE: The worst record covers ever

Ted,

That is pretty bad - but it does show an ounce of imagination (only an ounce, though), whereas the Kazevin cover has none whatsoever - even the positioning of the text around the cover is dull.

tjh212@yahoo.com
tjh212@yahoo.com's picture
Offline
Joined: 3rd Aug 2010
Posts: 13
RE: The worst record covers ever

"For Karajan, [the Bruckner bird wing covers] were models of what good record sleeve should be"

p. 604 "A Life in Music"

Adrian
Adrian's picture
Offline
Joined: 25th Nov 2010
Posts: 56
RE: The worst record covers ever

The Galleria series L.P/ C.D from DG and

the first "mid price cd's by Decca were awful and are almost gone.

Thank heaven for that.