What do you do with your covermount cd?

29 replies [Last post]
otterhouse
otterhouse's picture
Offline
Joined: 12th Mar 2010
Posts: 181
RE: What do you do with your covermount cd?

@Petra01

Plaatpaal has just been updated; Dvorak 7th symphony on a new Channel classics cd with Ivan Fischer, Nikolaj Znaider in Elgar's violin concerto and Handel's Venus and Adonis have been added:

http://www.radio4.nl/page/plaatpaal

Curious what you think of these performances!!

Greetings,

Rolf

Micos69
Micos69's picture
Offline
Joined: 30th Mar 2010
Posts: 109
RE: What do you do with your covermount cd?

I agree with the view that, although useful in the past, the sampler format to the covermount disc has been overtaken by alternatives available on the internet, and it is now time to end it.  I suggest that the present excellent series of talks on featured composers could be extended, with more musical examples, to fill the entire CD, with the competition remaining to test reader's CM knowledge.

matthewpiano
matthewpiano's picture
Offline
Joined: 21st Apr 2010
Posts: 23
RE: What do you do with your covermount cd?

Fully agree with the comments about the BBC Music covermount disc.  The recordings and performances are very often excellent and the discs really add value.

The Gramophone cover disc is interesting in a different way and I don't agree that the internet has made it dispensable.  I find it far more enjoyable to explore extracts from the month's recommended discs using my CD player than sitting at the computer and I would welcome a return to longer extracts.  The discussions and interviews are often very interesting but I would find longer extracts of music to be of more use.

Sifox211
Sifox211's picture
Offline
Joined: 20th May 2010
Posts: 28
RE: What do you do with your covermount cd?

I like the idea of the CD - especially for the samples - but find I rarely actually listen to the disk (most of mine are still in their shrinkwrap, and I still have everyone since they first appeared); I can't concentrate on it while doing something else (eg., driving) and if I'm going to sit down in front of the hifi for an hour, I'd rather listen to a whole work.

I did thoroughly enjoy the Mackerras Janacek interview - but I think that would be better done as a podcast.  Gramophone would be better dropping the disk (or make it optional for subscribers) and making whole tracks available for high quality download.

Good call from someone on charity shops - I can't bring myself to throw out all those jewel cases.  Are they actually interested in these CDs though?

Mike Carter
Mike Carter's picture
Offline
Joined: 16th Aug 2010
Posts: 1
RE: What do you do with your covermount cd?

Throw it away!  Now we seem to be no longer getting it in a jewel case, they're not even worth saving for that reason.  As a Gramophone reader for 40 years or so I would rather have a small reduction in the cover price.

BBC Music cover CDs can be really excellent, and certainly tempt me to buy that magazine on occasion, although Gramophone provides much better in-depth covergae overall.

__________________

Mike Carter

Micos69
Micos69's picture
Offline
Joined: 30th Mar 2010
Posts: 109
RE: What do you do with your covermount cd?

The Beeb have the boon of a vast archive of recordings for covermounts in its Musaic magazine, which gives what many might regard as an unfair advantage over competitors. I don't see how 'Gramophone' can do the same without some, maybe heavy, expense to itself.  However, the feature on a named composer, which I suggested some time ago could be extended, is definitely a 'winner', with the competition as a bonus at the end.

Sifox211
Sifox211's picture
Offline
Joined: 20th May 2010
Posts: 28
RE: What do you do with your covermount cd?

So! With the latest issue, it seems that G have been listening to us and are dropping the CD in favour of online streaming of longer tracks, some complete works from the archive and the features as podcasts!  Excellent.

I wonder if the complete works will be save-able or streaming only?

Wolfram
Wolfram's picture
Offline
Joined: 24th Aug 2010
Posts: 3
RE: What do you do with your covermount cd?

If you have cherry trees (or other fruit trees) in your garden, don't forget that unwanted CDs are excellent to keep blackbirds away from them.

Micos69
Micos69's picture
Offline
Joined: 30th Mar 2010
Posts: 109
RE: What do you do with your covermount cd?

With today's announcement about the Gramophone 'Player', this debate about the value of covermounts becomes rather academic.  However, they did serve their purpose, especially in the early years when they were a novelty.   

I hope that features like the competition and the 'Greatest Composer' sereies will continue, though - the announcement wan't clear on this.

Martin Cullingford
Martin Cullingford's picture
Offline
Joined: 6th Aug 2009
Posts: 254
RE: What do you do with your covermount cd?

There certainly will be a competition on the website, though it will be different from the one on the covermount, embracing sound, video and words. As for the Greatest Composer series, we are looking at putting the whole series online, and there are also plans for a new spoken word series. Watch this space, as they say.

 

 

__________________

Editor, Gramophone

phlogiston
phlogiston's picture
Offline
Joined: 16th Mar 2010
Posts: 175
RE: What do you do with your covermount cd?

What have I started?

Will the devotees of the CD still speak to me?

Will I be shunned in the clubs of London? "There goes the man who made the G drop its CD?"

P

rodwilliams
rodwilliams's picture
Offline
Joined: 4th Sep 2010
Posts: 2
RE: What do you do with your covermount cd?

I have always found covermount CDs invaluable, since inevitably - whatever one's level of familiarity with Classical Music, there will always be an artist or composer one has not heard before. The CDs from Gramophone, or other magazines, have in the past introduced me to music I wouldn't otherwise have heard, and in many cases I have bought the relevant full-length CD and hopefully broadened my musical experience.

In practical terms, I copy the CD to my mp3 player in order that I can listen to the relevant tracks in tandem with reading the reviews. Then, I tend to pass the CD on to interested friends. The burned copies I save on an external hard drive for reference.

I'd be very disappointed if the CD were discontinued. I know it may sound like a bit of an OCD CD thing, but it's my OCD CD thing, and I'm perfectly happy with it.

 

 

__________________

Roddy Williams

PSARenaud
PSARenaud's picture
Offline
Joined: 5th May 2010
Posts: 4
RE: What do you do with your covermount cd?

I usually listen to all tracks in sort of fast forward mode. It adds value for me. I would like to see the grammophone player to include these tracks (and possibility in a high res (FLAC) downloadable form) and can be expanded to more tracks and or video. The actual physical disc can be skipped. The Grammophone player can be made more flexible to include more podcasts and or video's.

__________________
ignaceII
ignaceII's picture
Offline
Joined: 9th Jan 2011
Posts: 1
RE: What do you do with your covermount cd?

Has anyone an idea to obtain older recordings in the plaatpaal radio4.

Ok, By playing with the url on top (changing the number at the end) I get them, but without cd info. It's gessing what cd the tracks come from.

I used to find a place on another website where more cds were covered, but I don't find it anymore. 

The buttons prev and next in the plaatpaal are disabled on my mac.

 

Thanks