Karajan Hall of Fame disc

16 replies [Last post]
VicJayL
VicJayL's picture
Offline
Joined: 16th Aug 2010
Posts: 762

What did others think of the two versions?  I thought them tremendous.  What a gem of a give-away!    Are others to follow in a Hall of Fame series?

Vic.

Uber Alice
Uber Alice's picture
Offline
Joined: 29th Mar 2012
Posts: 223
RE: Karajan Hall of Fame disc

More Karajan, just what we all needed. Did this disc come with a nice picture of herr Karajan on the front. Flying a plane, sailing a yacht, driving a fast car, he would have liked that. What a marketing mans dream he was. Or was he just gazing up with his eyes closed trying to count his deutsche marks.

VicJayL
VicJayL's picture
Offline
Joined: 16th Aug 2010
Posts: 762
RE: Karajan Hall of Fame disc

Uber Alice wrote:
More Karajan, just what we all needed. Did this disc come with a nice picture of herr Karajan on the front. Flying a plane, sailing a yacht, driving a fast car, he would have liked that. What a marketing mans dream he was. Or was he just gazing up with his eyes closed trying to count his deutsche marks.

I just enjoyed the music, Herr Brodsky.  I take it you didn't?  

Vic.

phlogiston
phlogiston's picture
Offline
Joined: 16th Mar 2010
Posts: 175
RE: Karajan Hall of Fame disc

Thank you Gramophone, for the attractive looking CD that arrived this morning. I am anticipating enjoying it. It will enhance the P CD collection nicely. I hope that it contributes to sales in newsagents and boosts circulation.

Best wishes,

P

troyen1
troyen1's picture
Offline
Joined: 9th Oct 2010
Posts: 716
RE: Karajan Hall of Fame disc

I have never heard his Beethoven 5 but I had the Brahms 2nd coupled with the 'Unfinished' on a Gramophone recommendation.

I liked neither and the CD was dispatched to musicmagpie.

However, I am pleased with the free gift and look forward to listening to it although the photo on the cover of  Karajan in a Formula 1 car is a bit hard to take!

I prefer the one of him piloting his jet!

Uber Alice
Uber Alice's picture
Offline
Joined: 29th Mar 2012
Posts: 223
RE: Karajan Hall of Valhala

It's a good job the alies won the war (Now we only need to look at Karajans teutonic mug shot when the Gramophone team up with Universal) We could have all been instructed to worship the divine one otherwise.

troyen1
troyen1's picture
Offline
Joined: 9th Oct 2010
Posts: 716
RE: Karajan Hall of Valhala

Uber Alice wrote:
It's a good job the alies won the war (Now we only need to look at Karajans teutonic mug shot when the Gramophone team up with Universal) We could have all been instructed to worship the divine one otherwise.

Alies? Oh, never mind.

Is this the best we can expect from you or are we to put up with more of this kind of thing?

VicJayL
VicJayL's picture
Offline
Joined: 16th Aug 2010
Posts: 762
RE: Karajan Hall of Valhala

troyen1 wrote:

Uber Alice wrote:
It's a good job the alies won the war (Now we only need to look at Karajans teutonic mug shot when the Gramophone team up with Universal) We could have all been instructed to worship the divine one otherwise.

Alies? Oh, never mind.

Is this the best we can expect from you or are we to put up with more of this kind of thing?

As we are dealing with the oh-so-transparent Brodsky Pimpanell here, I trust your question is rhetorical, troyen?

Vic.

phlogiston
phlogiston's picture
Offline
Joined: 16th Mar 2010
Posts: 175
RE: Karajan Hall of Fame disc

troyen1 wrote:

However, I am pleased with the free gift and look forward to listening to it although the photo on the cover of  Karajan in a Formula 1 car is a bit hard to take!

They must have printed a different sleeve for you! Mine has HvK looking thoughtfully at his baton.

Best wishes,

P

Hugh Farquhar
Hugh Farquhar's picture
Offline
Joined: 4th Apr 2012
Posts: 155
RE: Karajan Hall of Fame disc

phlogiston wrote:

troyen1 wrote:

However, I am pleased with the free gift and look forward to listening to it although the photo on the cover of  Karajan in a Formula 1 car is a bit hard to take!

They must have printed a different sleeve for you! Mine has HvK looking thoughtfully at his baton.

Best wishes,

P

Any suggestions as to where HvK could put his baton.

__________________
parla
parla's picture
Offline
Joined: 6th Aug 2011
Posts: 1816
RE: Karajan Hall of Fame disc

Another abominable descent to the abysmal darkness of human nature, dear Hugh? (Or is a legitimate rhetorical question?)

Parla

 

troyen1
troyen1's picture
Offline
Joined: 9th Oct 2010
Posts: 716
RE: Karajan Hall of Fame disc

phlogiston wrote:

troyen1 wrote:

However, I am pleased with the free gift and look forward to listening to it although the photo on the cover of  Karajan in a Formula 1 car is a bit hard to take!

They must have printed a different sleeve for you! Mine has HvK looking thoughtfully at his baton.

Best wishes,

P

Oh, you are spot on. I must have mixed it up with another Karajan disc of my imagining or was I having a dig at the Brodskysaur?

You decide.

troyen1
troyen1's picture
Offline
Joined: 9th Oct 2010
Posts: 716
RE: Karajan Hall of Fame disc

Hugh Farquhar wrote:
phlogiston wrote:

troyen1 wrote:

However, I am pleased with the free gift and look forward to listening to it although the photo on the cover of  Karajan in a Formula 1 car is a bit hard to take!

They must have printed a different sleeve for you! Mine has HvK looking thoughtfully at his baton.

Best wishes,

P

Any suggestions as to where HvK could put his baton.

He can use it to burst the 'Hall of Fame' babblers.

tjh212@yahoo.com
tjh212@yahoo.com's picture
Offline
Joined: 3rd Aug 2010
Posts: 13
RE: Karajan Hall of Fame disc

"HvK looking thoughtfully at his baton."

K dropped the stick during the Sinfonia Domestica recording session. For me one of his best records.

In the Bolero DVD concert he conducted the pieces before it with baton and Bolero without. The
piece just before Bolero in the actual concert was cut on the DVD, so not sure where he put it.

troyen1
troyen1's picture
Offline
Joined: 9th Oct 2010
Posts: 716
RE: Karajan Hall of Fame disc

tjh212@yahoo.com wrote:
"HvK looking thoughtfully at his baton." K dropped the stick during the Sinfonia Domestica recording session. For me one of his best records. In the Bolero DVD concert he conducted the pieces before it with baton and Bolero without. The piece just before Bolero in the actual concert was cut on the DVD, so not sure where he put it.

Karajan seems to get a lot of stick, still.

japan
japan's picture
Offline
Joined: 15th Apr 2012
Posts: 4
RE: Karajan Hall of Fame disc

I like this version of Brahms 2-the Woodwind are a particular joy eg.1:07 and 2:07 of the Finale. The same moments in the 70s BPO recording pass by less strikingly, to my mind.