Turnage (The) Silver Tassie
A BARGAIN RELEASE FOR AN OPERA THAT COULD BE DESTINED FOR A PERMANENT PLACE IN THE REPERTOIRE
View record and artist detailsRecord and Artist Details
Composer or Director: Mark-Anthony Turnage, Albert Dohmen
Genre:
Opera
Label: ENO Alive
Magazine Review Date: 10/2002
Media Format: CD or Download
Media Runtime: 110
Mastering:
Stereo
DDD
Catalogue Number: ENOALIVE001
Tracks:
Composition | Artist Credit |
---|---|
(The) Silver Tassie |
Mark-Anthony Turnage, Composer
Albert Dohmen, Composer Christine Buffle, Vixen, Soprano English National Opera Chorus English National Opera Orchestra Geraint Evans, Nightwatchman, Bass Grant Doyle, Forester, Baritone Heinz Kruse, Guido Bardi, Tenor Iris Vermillion, Bianca, Soprano Katarina Giotas, Owl; Forester's Wife Mark Wilde, Woodpecker, Tenor Mark-Anthony Turnage, Composer Matthew Smith, Frog Michelle Sheridan, Hen Paul Daniel, Conductor Peter Van Hulle, Schoolmaster Richard Roberts, Cock, Tenor |
Author:
It says a good deal about the state of the record industry that this world première recording of MarkAnthony Turnage’s second eveninglength opera should launch ENO’s inhouse label. Its stage predecessor‚ an adaptation of Steve Berkoff’s Greek (1988)‚ was a jewel in the crown of the latelamented Argo label (7/94)‚ yet it is the new work that has the greater potential audience appeal.
The Silver Tassie stakes out its claim to a permanent place in the repertoire by engaging our sympathies as surely as Wozzeck or West Side Story‚ deploying a musical idiom that sits somewhere between these two‚ with Tippett‚ Britten and Knussen the most obvious direct influences. Whatever the models‚ Turnage’s soundworld is never less than intensely personal‚ trademark wailing saxophones and all‚ and his instinct for musical demotic is at its very best in the dance genre allusions of the final act.
Some background may be helpful to the uninitiated. The libretto is based on Sean O’Casey’s Dublinset‚ antiwar play of 1928. The vigorous First Act presents the main characters and gives them a real social context. The hero is – or turns out to be – Harry Heegan‚ who‚ while on leave from the trenches in 1915‚ brings home the eponymous tassie – a football trophy.
Turnage ingeniously adopts a more overtly tonal idiom at salient points‚ ensuring that the work’s football theme is easy to pick up. When the men are called back to the front‚ we are pitched into a static tableau that risks seeming merely flat after all that kinetic activity. Without the visual element‚ the combination of Tippettian harmony and Brittenish choral writing doesn’t quite come off.
The action picks up in the Dublin hospital ward of Act 3. With Harry paralysed from the waist down and his neighbour Teddy blinded‚ we discover that Harry’s girlfriend has deserted him for his (ablebodied) best friend. The rest of the drama contrasts Harry’s current plight with his former glory and ultimately addresses the need for us all to move on and live our lives. There is some wonderfully poignant music of loss and despair in Act 4‚ Turnage’s newfound delicacy and introspection complementing his earlier preoccupation with busy surface activity.
The present set‚ lavishly packaged for a bargain release‚ was taped during the opera’s original run rather than the recent revival and hence can boast Gerald Finley’s magnificent‚ definitive Harry Heegan. The veteran Gwynne Howell‚ taking the awkwardly symbolic role of The Croucher‚ is Act 2’s prophet of doom‚ while Sarah Connolly works wonders with Susie‚ the insistently religious neighbourturnednurse. The minor characters are well characterised‚ even where the Irish accent comes and goes.
Live recording brings the usual mix of losses and gains. Finley’s personal triumph is well conveyed‚ although he does wander offmike in the key football song (CD 1 track 10). Generally speaking‚ the words are far clearer than they could ever be in the opera house. That close focus is rather less sympathetic when it comes to the choral singing of Act 2‚ with the usual flaws in the contribution of the stretcherbearing boys.
I should mention that enthusiastic applause is (briefly) retained; O’Casey’s antiwar theme and sympathetic deconstruction of masculine bravado obviously struck a chord. You can buy the set online but I wouldn’t advise that you drop into the Coliseum foyer as the site suggests – it’s currently a building site.
Explore the world’s largest classical music catalogue on Apple Music Classical.
Included with an Apple Music subscription. Download now.
Gramophone Digital Club
- Digital Edition
- Digital Archive
- Reviews Database
- Events & Offers
From £9.20 / month
SubscribeGramophone Club
- Print Edition
- Digital Edition
- Digital Archive
- Reviews Database
- Events & Offers
From £11.45 / month
Subscribe
If you are a library, university or other organisation that would be interested in an institutional subscription to Gramophone please click here for further information.