The Gramophone Choice
Acis and Galatea (original Cannons 1718 version)
Susan Hamilton (sop) Galatea Nicholas Mulroy (ten) Acis Matthew Brook (bass) Polyphemus Thomas Hobbs (ten) Damon Nicholas Hurndall Smith (ten) Coridon Dunedin Consort & Players / John Butt
Linn CKD319 (95’ · DDD · T). Buy from Amazon
Handel’s Acis and Galatea has been recorded often but the original version, written for small-scale performance by only five singers (soprano, three tenors and bass) and a small band at Cannons in 1718, has almost never been properly revived. This beggars belief because the Cannons version text makes more dramatic sense and the musical scale of it is charming. It is certainly among Handel’s most perfect creations. Thankfully, John Butt has researched the performing conditions and text of the Cannons Acis. The philological aspects of the Dunedin Consort & Players’ new recording are impeccable and, better still, the performance is utterly magical.
The Sinfonia brims with unforced personality, after which the pastoral chorus ‘O the pleasure of the plains’ is relaxed, with the oboes given enough space to weave their imitative lines clearly. The five singers and the band are beautifully in proportion with each other and Linn’s sound recording is stunningly good. Susan Hamilton’s light, articulate soprano is preferable to an operatic voice in the role of Galatea. Nicholas Mulroy’s Acis is resonant and suave, combining muscularity with elegance. The madrigal-like beauty of ‘Wretched lovers’ is breathtaking: the blend and understanding between the five singers are deeply satisfying, and the menacing music to convey the arrival of Polyphemus is astutely integrated. Matthew Brook’s Polyphemus is extrovert, powerful and amusing but also arouses pity and tenderness from the listener in ‘I rage, I melt, I burn’. The dialogue between the hapless would-be seducer and the disgusted Galatea is superbly enacted by Brook and Hamilton. The roles of Damon and Coridon are admirably sung by Nicholas Hurndall Smith and Thomas Hobbs.
Butt’s direction from the harpsichord is a model of taste and style, and he insightfully conveys the elusive changing tone of the story from pastoral romp into personal tragedy. Previous versions of merit still possess enduring appeal but the Dunedins have transformed the way in which we can understand and enjoy Handel’s lovely early English masterpiece.
Acis and Galatea (arr Mendelssohn)
Julia Kleiter (sop) Galatea Christoph Prégardien (ten) Acis Wolf Matthias Friedrich (bass) Polyphemus Michael Slattery (ten) Damon North German Radio Choir; Göttingen Festival Orchestra / Nicholas McGegan
Carus CARUS83 420 (73’ · DDD/DSD · T/t) Buy from Amazon
The virtues of Acis and Galatea were clear enough more than a century later for the 19‑year-old Mendelssohn to arrange the work for the Berlin Sing-Akademie in 1828‑29 (with a German version of the libretto prepared by his sister Fanny). One might uncharitably (but accurately) criticise that the teenage Mendelssohn’s feverish excitement at discovering Handel led to him throwing everything he could (almost including the kitchen sink, so it seems) at the music. Unlike Mozart’s more discreet and softer reorchestration of Acis (1788), there is an intense amount of intervention in Mendelssohn’s orchestral score, which is tailored for a full-scale symphony orchestra and large chorus.
Nicholas McGegan and his Göttingen Festival Orchestra gave the modern premiere of Mendelssohn’s score at the 2008 Göttingen Handel Festival, and the ensuing recording is crisply detailed. The most amusing effects are huge bursts of brass and timpani explosions associated with Polyphemus, who is sung with gusto by Wolf Matthias Friedrich. Acis is sung with a hint of strain by Christoph Prégardien, and Julia Kleiter’s Galatea is efficient.
The NDR Choir are jovial or doleful as the music requires. McGegan directs with liveliness, and it’s hard to imagine this arrangement receiving a better advocate. It’s bombastic and clumsy in comparison to Handel’s delightful original, but the young Mendelssohn’s perspective is entertaining.