Goldenthal A Vietnam Oratorio
View record and artist detailsRecord and Artist Details
Composer or Director: Elliot B. Goldenthal
Label: Classical
Magazine Review Date: 6/1996
Media Format: CD or Download
Media Runtime: 65
Mastering:
DDD
Catalogue Number: SK68368
Tracks:
| Composition | Artist Credit |
|---|---|
| Fire Water Paper: A Vietnam Oratorio |
Elliot B. Goldenthal, Composer
Ann Panagulias, Soprano Carl St Clair, Conductor Elliot B. Goldenthal, Composer James Maddalena, Baritone Ngan-Khoi Vietnamese Children's Chorus Pacific Chorale Pacific Chorale Children's Chorus Pacific Symphony Orchestra Yo-Yo Ma, Cello |
Author: Andrew Achenbach
A pupil of John Corigliano and Aaron Copland, Brooklyn-born Elliot Goldenthal (b. 1954) is perhaps best-known for his highly imaginative, often stunningly effective film music (recent blockbuster projects have included Batman Forever, Interview with the Vampire and Heat). Goldenthal has, however, composed fluently in many other fields. Notable achievements include the theatrical-oratorio Juan Darien, A Carnival Mass, the musicals The Transposed Heads and Liberty’s Taken, Shadow Play Scherzo for orchestra, the song-cycle Los Heraldos Negros, as well as copious incidental music for the theatre.
Fire Water Paper: A Vietnam Oratorio was commissioned by the Pacific Symphony Orchestra to commemorate the twentieth anniversary of the end of the Vietnam War. The first of its three movements, a large-scale “Offertorium” which the composer has likened to a slowly unfolding passion play, weaves Buddhist and Catholic texts around two more extended settings: the first comprises a statement left by Nat Chi Mai, a student activist who torched herself to death in protest against the war (“I wish to use my body as a torch to dissipate the darkness, to waken love among men and to bring peace to Vietnam”); the second is a poem by the Vietnam veteran and Pulitzer Prize-winning poet Yusef Komunyakaa entitled You and I Are Disappearing, which describes the horror of seeing a young girl’s burning body. Fire and self-sacrifice are the twin metaphors here (according to the composer the latter theme’s strong parallels with the Stabat mater unlocked the key to his selection of texts), whereas in the succeeding Scherzo it is paper. This feverish dance of death (which bears the subtitle giang co or “tug-of-war”) utilizes a far-ranging assortment of documents – from Virgil, Tacitus and Cicero to terms used in the Vietnam conflict – all designed to illustrate the folly of war. By contrast, the concluding “Hymn” breathes a more conciliatory, though never entirely comforting air. This time the theme is water. The movement’s centrepiece – an affecting setting of a poem (again by Yusef Komunyakaa) describing the plight of the boat-people – is framed by words taken from the Book of Jeremiah (“... a vast company, they come home, weeping as they come, but I shall comfort them and be their escort, and I shall lead them by streams of water; their path will be smooth, they will not stumble. They will not fall.”).
The imaginative flair and extraordinary assurance with which Goldenthal deploys his vast forces will come as no surprise to anyone who has heard his work for the cinema. The manner of the whole is unashamedly rhetorical, the mood by turns anguished, compassionate and memorably serene. Stylistic echoes are legion – Mahler (and the Tenth Symphony in particular – try from 3'39'' into the “Hymn”), Shostakovich (the orchestral introduction to the Scherzo, for example), Bloch, Britten, Corigliano – yet Goldenthal’s own brand of bittersweet lyricism and irresistible orchestral physicality are everywhere in evidence.
Suffice to say, the performance is all one could wish. Choral focus could be sharper; otherwise, the sound is spectacular. Fire Water Paper will, perhaps almost inevitably, find a greater market on the other side of the Atlantic, but it remains an admirably ambitious, heartfelt creation which all admirers of this talented, versatile figure will rightly want to investigate.'
The imaginative flair and extraordinary assurance with which Goldenthal deploys his vast forces will come as no surprise to anyone who has heard his work for the cinema. The manner of the whole is unashamedly rhetorical, the mood by turns anguished, compassionate and memorably serene. Stylistic echoes are legion – Mahler (and the Tenth Symphony in particular – try from 3'39'' into the “Hymn”), Shostakovich (the orchestral introduction to the Scherzo, for example), Bloch, Britten, Corigliano – yet Goldenthal’s own brand of bittersweet lyricism and irresistible orchestral physicality are everywhere in evidence.
Suffice to say, the performance is all one could wish. Choral focus could be sharper; otherwise, the sound is spectacular. Fire Water Paper will, perhaps almost inevitably, find a greater market on the other side of the Atlantic, but it remains an admirably ambitious, heartfelt creation which all admirers of this talented, versatile figure will rightly want to investigate.'
Goldenthal A Vietnam Oratorio
Explore the world’s largest classical music catalogue on Apple Music Classical.
Included with an Apple Music subscription. Download now.
Gramophone Digital Club
- Digital Edition
- Digital Archive
- Reviews Database
- Full website access
From £8.75 / month
Subscribe
Gramophone Full Club
- Print Edition
- Digital Edition
- Digital Archive
- Reviews Database
- Full website access
From £11.00 / month
Subscribe
If you are a library, university or other organisation that would be interested in an institutional subscription to Gramophone please click here for further information.