Berlioz (L') Enfance du Christ
A good ‘pre-authentic’ recording, though short on drama and passion
View record and artist detailsRecord and Artist Details
Composer or Director: Hector Berlioz
Genre:
DVD
Label: Video Artists International
Magazine Review Date: 7/2005
Media Format: Digital Versatile Disc
Media Runtime: 107
Mastering:
Stereo
Catalogue Number: VAIDVD4303

Tracks:
Composition | Artist Credit |
---|---|
(L') Enfance du Christ |
Hector Berlioz, Composer
Boston Symphony Orchestra Charles Munch, Conductor Donald Gramm, Bass Florence Kopleff, Contralto (Female alto) Harvard Glee Club Hector Berlioz, Composer John McCollum, Tenor Radcliffe Choral Society Theodor Uppman, Baritone |
Author: mscott rohan
This is historically fascinating, perhaps more so for US readers. Munch was the great Berlioz interpreter in an era when the composer was still undervalued, but among ‘pre-authentic’ recordings, Brits tend to identify with Sir Colin Davis’s more impassioned style.
Munch here displays very much the virtues and vices of his earlier sound recording, in particular his warmly affectionate reading, well paced if occasionally inclined to languish. This was his last guest appearance with the orchestra he directed for 13 years, and they play superbly. The effect, though, is altogether too smooth and inflexible, in the brass especially. Drama and tension rarely break the surface, to anextent aficionados of Gardiner or Herreweghe may find dull.
The voices also reflect this. The chorus, centred on Harvard’s famous Glee Club, sing with splendid precision and control (a poetic ‘Shepherd’s Farewell’) but not much expression and rather stilted French, which also afflicts John McCollum’s otherwise pleasantly plangent Narrator. Florence Kopleff’s Mary, the only soloist in common with the sound recording, is pure-toned but indistinct. Theodor Uppman is rather better as Joseph, thanks to excellent diction, if less natural than the audio version’s Gérard Souzay. Most distinguished of all is Donald Gramm, elegant, eloquent and mellow-toned – just too poised and uncompelling a Herod. Why chorister Donald Meades took Polydorus’s final line is inexplicable.
As a recording this is unexpectedly good, the video direction a model of unobtrusive clarity – and immortalising the inevitable latecomers! – the black-and-white picture reasonably crisp, the sound, though mono, very decent. If Munch appeals, it’s well worth having; and other recordings promised from the Boston archives will be eagerly awaited.
Munch here displays very much the virtues and vices of his earlier sound recording, in particular his warmly affectionate reading, well paced if occasionally inclined to languish. This was his last guest appearance with the orchestra he directed for 13 years, and they play superbly. The effect, though, is altogether too smooth and inflexible, in the brass especially. Drama and tension rarely break the surface, to anextent aficionados of Gardiner or Herreweghe may find dull.
The voices also reflect this. The chorus, centred on Harvard’s famous Glee Club, sing with splendid precision and control (a poetic ‘Shepherd’s Farewell’) but not much expression and rather stilted French, which also afflicts John McCollum’s otherwise pleasantly plangent Narrator. Florence Kopleff’s Mary, the only soloist in common with the sound recording, is pure-toned but indistinct. Theodor Uppman is rather better as Joseph, thanks to excellent diction, if less natural than the audio version’s Gérard Souzay. Most distinguished of all is Donald Gramm, elegant, eloquent and mellow-toned – just too poised and uncompelling a Herod. Why chorister Donald Meades took Polydorus’s final line is inexplicable.
As a recording this is unexpectedly good, the video direction a model of unobtrusive clarity – and immortalising the inevitable latecomers! – the black-and-white picture reasonably crisp, the sound, though mono, very decent. If Munch appeals, it’s well worth having; and other recordings promised from the Boston archives will be eagerly awaited.
Discover the world's largest classical music catalogue with Presto Music.

Gramophone Digital Club
- Digital Edition
- Digital Archive
- Reviews Database
- Full website access
From £8.75 / month
Subscribe
Gramophone Full Club
- Print Edition
- Digital Edition
- Digital Archive
- Reviews Database
- Full website access
From £11.00 / month
Subscribe
If you are a library, university or other organisation that would be interested in an institutional subscription to Gramophone please click here for further information.