Nielsen Flute and Clarinet Concertos; Wind Quintet
Polished and poised – is that the Nielsen way? Great Quintet, though
View record and artist detailsRecord and Artist Details
Composer or Director: Carl Nielsen
Genre:
Orchestral
Label: EMI Classics
Magazine Review Date: 13/2007
Media Format: CD or Download
Media Runtime: 69
Mastering:
Stereo
DDD
Catalogue Number: 394421-2
Tracks:
Composition | Artist Credit |
---|---|
Concerto for Flute and Orchestra |
Carl Nielsen, Composer
Berlin Philharmonic Orchestra Carl Nielsen, Composer Emmanuel Pahud, Flute Simon Rattle, Conductor |
Wind Quintet |
Carl Nielsen, Composer
Berlin Philharmonic Orchestra (members) Carl Nielsen, Composer |
Concerto for Clarinet and Orchestra |
Carl Nielsen, Composer
Berlin Philharmonic Orchestra Carl Nielsen, Composer Sabine Meyer, Clarinet Simon Rattle, Conductor |
Author: David Fanning
Nielsen’s two woodwind concertos and the genial quintet that prepared the way for those later, more acerbic works make a natural, though I think unprecedented, coupling on CD; and now that the starry team on this new disc has done it, any successors are going to find it hard to compete. Hard, but not impossible.
These are technically consummate performances – not something to be taken for granted, because the concertos in particular are not pieces even the most complete virtuoso could hope to pick up casually. It is undeniable, too, that a wealth of imagination has gone into the interpretations, not least in the accompaniments. What emerges is so polished and poetic, however, that those used to the sturdier old Danish tradition may feel that almost as much has been lost as gained.
Pahud’s approach is clear enough from his first phrase, moulded with a seductive eloquence that borders on the self-conscious. Yet Nielsen’s own programme-note talked of the “free, fantasising tone”, with the soloist moving “rather searchingly”, and reheard in the context of Pahud’s overall view of the piece, his phrasing is persuasive enough.
If the Clarinet Concerto has rarely sounded as poised or as reflective, that may be largely a function of Sabine Meyer’s impeccable technique. All the same, a little more self-assertiveness would not have done the music any harm, and for anyone who feels that irascibility and harshness is of the essence in this piece, such civilised playing will be no substitute for the tousled unkemptness of Ib Eriksson’s 1954 account.
Orchestral principals do not always make ideal chamber partners. But the Berliners’ account of the much-recorded Quintet is simply wonderful: surpassingly suave, again as one might expect, but also full of grace, wit and fantasy, plus the larger-than-life characterisation in the finale that I missed in the otherwise excellent recent version from the Copenhagen-based Diamant Ensemble.
These are technically consummate performances – not something to be taken for granted, because the concertos in particular are not pieces even the most complete virtuoso could hope to pick up casually. It is undeniable, too, that a wealth of imagination has gone into the interpretations, not least in the accompaniments. What emerges is so polished and poetic, however, that those used to the sturdier old Danish tradition may feel that almost as much has been lost as gained.
Pahud’s approach is clear enough from his first phrase, moulded with a seductive eloquence that borders on the self-conscious. Yet Nielsen’s own programme-note talked of the “free, fantasising tone”, with the soloist moving “rather searchingly”, and reheard in the context of Pahud’s overall view of the piece, his phrasing is persuasive enough.
If the Clarinet Concerto has rarely sounded as poised or as reflective, that may be largely a function of Sabine Meyer’s impeccable technique. All the same, a little more self-assertiveness would not have done the music any harm, and for anyone who feels that irascibility and harshness is of the essence in this piece, such civilised playing will be no substitute for the tousled unkemptness of Ib Eriksson’s 1954 account.
Orchestral principals do not always make ideal chamber partners. But the Berliners’ account of the much-recorded Quintet is simply wonderful: surpassingly suave, again as one might expect, but also full of grace, wit and fantasy, plus the larger-than-life characterisation in the finale that I missed in the otherwise excellent recent version from the Copenhagen-based Diamant Ensemble.
Explore the world’s largest classical music catalogue on Apple Music Classical.
Included with an Apple Music subscription. Download now.
Gramophone Digital Club
- Digital Edition
- Digital Archive
- Reviews Database
- Events & Offers
From £9.20 / month
SubscribeGramophone Club
- Print Edition
- Digital Edition
- Digital Archive
- Reviews Database
- Events & Offers
From £11.45 / month
Subscribe
If you are a library, university or other organisation that would be interested in an institutional subscription to Gramophone please click here for further information.