TCHAIKOVSKY The Queen of Spades (Jansons)

Record and Artist Details

Composer or Director: Pyotr Ilyich Tchaikovsky



Label: C Major

Media Format: Digital Versatile Disc



Catalogue Number: 801408

801408. TCHAIKOVSKY The Queen of Spades (Jansons)


Composition Artist Credit
(The) Queen of Spades, 'Pique Dame' Gleb Peryazev
Igor Golovatenko
Vienna State Opera Chorus
Pavel Petrov
Salzburg Festival Children’s and Theatre Choir
Stanislav Trofimov
Oksana Volkova
Brandon Jovanovich
Pyotr Ilyich Tchaikovsky Composer
Hanna Schwarz
Vienna Philharmonic Orchestra
Evgenia Muraveva
Vladislav Sulimsky
Mariss Jansons
Alexander Kravets
Mariss Jansons has played many hands of The Queen of Spades. Within the past decade alone, the Latvian conductor has recorded Tchaikovsky’s psychodrama with the Bavarian Radio Symphony Orchestra and led performances at the Dutch National Opera with the Royal Concertgebouw that were recorded for DVD/Blu ray. Now comes another production taped for the same format from the 2018 Salzburg Festival.

Why did Jansons roll the dice again? Well, the Vienna Philharmonic probably sweetened the deal. They are the aces in the pack here and play with silken elegance, particularly those walnut-toned strings. Jansons’s adoration for the music is clear, and the glitter and allure of the score is almost tangible. His languorous tempo choices, on the other hand, can err to the self-indulgent. This opera is a ghost story and a thriller (with a brilliant twist ending) but Jansons is not one to turn the screw.

If the music sounds sumptuous, however, it’s mostly gritty austerity on stage. Seventeen years after Hans Neuenfels created a local scandal in his Salzburg staging of Die Fledermaus, he returns with an emotionally neutral production. Christian Schmidt’s sets – mostly midnight blue and voluminous black – are the bare frame for costumes (Reinhard von der Thannen) that include Hermann’s toy-soldier uniform, mysteriously minus a shirt, fetish-style rubber and, for the women’s chorus, exaggerated saggy breasts. This is essentially a study of a society in decay, in which the lead characters seek only a way out. When Catherine the Great makes her cameo at the end of Act 2, she is greeted as ‘our tender mother’ but represented by a gaudy skeleton.

There is some striking imagery here but this opera demands a creepier seam, as well as some old-fashioned coups de théâtre. Neuenfels seems determined to avoid such splashy theatrics, which leaves his cast a little rudderless and makes the wide-open stage of the Grosses Festspielhaus look even more vast. Hanna Schwarz’s veteran Countess has the right raddled energy for the role and her death – utterly bald, she gratefully reaches for Hermann’s revolver – is suitably yucky; but there’s no real context for her character and her spooky return from the grave is underwhelming. Likewise, Evgenia Muraveva’s Lisa, who sings with impressive, even tone, is not supported by all the studied blankness around her.

There is more to get your teeth into from Brandon Jovanovich’s committed Herman, sung with surprisingly graceful suppleness (if pushed at times), and from Igor Golovatenko’s impassioned Yeletsky, much more than the usual princely patsy. Vladislav Sulimsky’s Tomsky provides decent support but his pivotal narration is under-energised. All in all, there is serious quality here but piquancy is what this Pique Dame is lacking.

Gramophone Print

  • Print Edition

From £67/year


The Gramophone Digital Club

  • Digital Edition
  • Digital Archive
  • Reviews Database
  • Events & Offers

From £90/year


Gramophone Reviews

  • Reviews Database

From £67/year


Gramophone Digital Edition

  • Digital Edition
  • Digital Archive

From £67/year


If you are a library, university or other organisation that would be interested in an institutional subscription to Gramophone please click here for further information.