Verdi Falstaff

Record and Artist Details

Composer or Director: Giuseppe Verdi



Label: Great Recordings of the Century

Media Format: CD or Download



Catalogue Number: 567083-2


Composition Artist Credit
Falstaff Tito Gobbi
Anna Moffo
Nicola Zaccaria
Nan Merriman
Philharmonia Orchestra
Luigi Alva
Herbert von Karajan
Renato Ercolani
Elisabeth Schwarzkopf
Tomaso Spataro
Fedora Barbieri
Giuseppe Verdi Composer
Rolando Panerai
After one has grown up with a much-loved recording, no other ever seems to match it. That is the case for me with this Falstaff: none of the recordings that have come along subsequently – 15 are listed on the current Gramophone Database, not including videos – has come close to what Karajan and his hand-picked cast achieved in Kingsway Hall, London, in June 1956. It will surely prove difficult to surpass its particular combination of virtues.
What are they? Foremost was EMI’s ability in the 1950s to bring together a cast of big personalities and weld them into a true ensemble. As Falstaff is the ensemble opera par excellence, it is no surprise that the policy should have been such a success here. Maybe Elisabeth Schwarzkopf tries to score points too often as Alice Ford, but Nan Merriman is a fine Meg and Fedora Barbieri, though working her fruity chest-notes a touch coarsely, does not miss a trick as Mistress Quickly. In Ford’s big scena Rolando Panerai fails to tune in to the comic melodrama, but he sings well and earns bonus points for taking the great closing phrase in a single arc. A glimpse of perfection is provided by each fleeting appearance of the two young lovers, Luigi Alva light as thistledown in his solo and Anna Moffo touching upon moon-lit top notes as the Queen of the Fairies. As the post-war owner of the title-role, Tito Gobbi is a completely authoritative Falstaff, who wisely leaves others to point the finger at the character’s buffoonery, and he always sings the notes, which he didn’t at his last appearances in the role at Covent Garden.
On all sides, not least the playing of the Philharmonia Orchestra, Karajan presides over the highest technical standards. Of course, the real Verdi lies elsewhere, with the fiery Toscanini for one, but the cultivated air that Karajan brings to Verdi never sounded better than in this Falstaff. What other conductor conjures such magic in the simple chords that accompany the 12 strokes of midnight under Herne’s Oak? Thanks to EMI’s remastering, the sound has more body and depth, and the hiss that was prevalent on previous CD reissues has been reduced: the assignation in Windsor Forest no longer seems to happen during a hailstorm. How appropriate that this evergreen performance should sound younger with each reappearance.'

Gramophone Print

  • Print Edition

From £67/year


The Gramophone Digital Club

  • Digital Edition
  • Digital Archive
  • Reviews Database
  • Events & Offers

From £90/year


Gramophone Reviews

  • Reviews Database

From £67/year


Gramophone Digital Edition

  • Digital Edition
  • Digital Archive

From £67/year


If you are a library, university or other organisation that would be interested in an institutional subscription to Gramophone please click here for further information.