Masters of the Piano Roll: Fauré & Strauss

Occasionally bewitching performances recreated from punched-card piano rolls

Record and Artist Details

Composer or Director: Georg Liebling, Gabriel Fauré, Manuel de Falla, Cyril (Meir) Scott, (Johann Baptist Joseph) Max(imilian) Reger, Raoul Laparra, Carlos (Léon) Salzedo, John (Nicholson) Ireland, Richard Strauss, Darius Milhaud, Alfred Grünfeld, (George) Percy (Aldridge) Grainger, Alfredo Casella, (Aynsley) Eugene Goossens

Genre:

Instrumental

Label: Dal Segno

Media Format: CD or Download

Media Runtime: 73

Mastering:

Mono
ADD

Catalogue Number: DSPRCD010

Tracks:

Composition Artist Credit
Salome Richard Strauss, Composer
Richard Strauss, Composer
Richard Strauss, Piano
(4) Pièces espagnoles, Movement: Aragonesa Manuel de Falla, Composer
Manuel de Falla, Piano
Manuel de Falla, Composer
(4) Pièces espagnoles, Movement: Cubana Manuel de Falla, Composer
Manuel de Falla, Piano
Manuel de Falla, Composer
Pavane Gabriel Fauré, Composer
Gabriel Fauré, Composer
Gabriel Fauré, Composer
Spanish Rhythms, Movement: Tientos Raoul Laparra, Composer
Raoul Laparra, Composer
Raoul Laparra, Piano
Spanish Rhythms, Movement: Calesera Raoul Laparra, Composer
Raoul Laparra, Composer
Raoul Laparra, Piano
Spanish Rhythms, Movement: Solea Raoul Laparra, Composer
Raoul Laparra, Composer
Raoul Laparra, Piano
Spanish Rhythms, Movement: Paseo Raoul Laparra, Composer
Raoul Laparra, Piano
Raoul Laparra, Composer
Souvenirs of Youth Raoul Laparra, Composer
Raoul Laparra, Composer
Raoul Laparra, Piano
(2) Musical relics of my Mother (George) Percy (Aldridge) Grainger, Composer
(George) Percy (Aldridge) Grainger, Composer
Percy Grainger, Piano
Rose Grainger, Piano
Caprice Chinois Cyril (Meir) Scott, Composer
Cyril (Meir) Scott, Composer
Cyril Scott, Piano
Danse nègre Cyril (Meir) Scott, Composer
Cyril (Meir) Scott, Composer
Cyril Scott, Piano
(2) Pieces, Movement: Lotus Land Cyril (Meir) Scott, Composer
Cyril (Meir) Scott, Composer
Cyril Scott, Piano
(2) Studies, Movement: Folk Tune (Aynsley) Eugene Goossens, Composer
(Aynsley) Eugene Goossens, Composer
(Aynsley) Eugene Goossens, Composer
Romanze Alfred Grünfeld, Composer
Alfred Grünfeld, Composer
Alfred Grünfeld, Piano
Reverie Carlos (Léon) Salzedo, Composer
Carlos (Léon) Salzedo, Composer
Carlos Salzedo, Piano
Saudades do Brasil Darius Milhaud, Composer
Darius Milhaud, Composer
Darius Milhaud, Piano
Barcarola (Capri) Georg Liebling, Composer
Georg Liebling, Piano
Georg Liebling, Composer
Inezie Alfredo Casella, Composer
Alfredo Casella, Piano
Alfredo Casella, Composer
London Pieces, Movement: Ragamuffin John (Nicholson) Ireland, Composer
John (Nicholson) Ireland, Composer
John Ireland, Piano
(2) Pieces, Movement: Amberley Wild Brooks John (Nicholson) Ireland, Composer
John (Nicholson) Ireland, Composer
John Ireland, Piano
(6) Intermezzi, Movement: G minor (Johann Baptist Joseph) Max(imilian) Reger, Composer
(Johann Baptist Joseph) Max(imilian) Reger, Composer
Max Reger, Piano
Stimmungsbilder, Movement: Auf stillen Waldespfad Richard Strauss, Composer
Richard Strauss, Piano
Richard Strauss, Composer
Composers perform. But Dal Segno does not say from which of the three electrically driven, but incompatible, systems – Welte-Mignon, Ampico and Duo Art – these rolls were produced. Playback is through ‘a brand new piano in a digital recording’, though the recording isn’t always satisfactory. The sound becomes shallow at high dynamic levels.

Not every composer is distinguished. Richard Strauss certainly is and his three recordings illustrate a point about this method of recording: what seems an amateurish performance doesn’t necessarily indicate an amateurish performer. Strauss is expressive and accomplished in Auf stillen Waldespfad but the excerpts from Salome are unsensuous or effortful. The discrepancy could be the result of poorly adjusted mechanisms, or shrinkage in ageing paper rolls.

There are two identifiable errors: what’s listed as John Ireland’s Ragamuffin on track 22 is Amberley Wildbrooks, while the following track, presumably meant to be Ragamuffin, is a repeat of Cyril Scott’s Chinese Caprice on track 14. Despite provisos, however, many of the rolls and systems appear unscathed by time and offer bewitching experiences, not least the sort of deep-toned pianism that isn’t often heard today – a reminder that, whatever the shortcomings, this medium is also a part of gramophone history.

Explore the world’s largest classical music catalogue on Apple Music Classical.

Included with an Apple Music subscription. Download now.

Gramophone Print

  • Print Edition

From £6.67 / month

Subscribe

Gramophone Digital Club

  • Digital Edition
  • Digital Archive
  • Reviews Database
  • Full website access

From £8.75 / month

Subscribe

                              

If you are a library, university or other organisation that would be interested in an institutional subscription to Gramophone please click here for further information.