Wagner Parsifal
A good stab at Parsifal but DVD cries out for better visuals
View record and artist detailsRecord and Artist Details
Composer or Director: Richard Wagner
Genre:
DVD
Label: Dynamic
Magazine Review Date: 3/2007
Media Format: Digital Versatile Disc
Media Runtime: 244
Mastering:
Stereo
Catalogue Number: DV33497

Tracks:
Composition | Artist Credit |
---|---|
Parsifal |
Richard Wagner, Composer
Camerata Silesia Catherine Cangiano, Flower Maiden I, Soprano Claudia Clarich, Voice from Above, Contralto (Female alto) Doris Soffel, Kundry, Mezzo soprano Elisabetta Martorana, Squire II, Soprano Elisabetta Martorana, Flower Maiden II, Soprano Elisabetta Martorana, Flower Maiden II, Soprano Elisabetta Martorana, Flower Maiden II, Soprano Elisabetta Martorana, Squire II, Soprano Elisabetta Martorana, Squire II, Soprano Federico Sacchi, Knight II, Bass Gabor Õtvös, Conductor Gianluca Moschetti, Squire IV, Tenor Iorio Zennaro, Knight I, Tenor Julie Mellor, Flower Maiden VI, Soprano Liesl Odenweller, Squire I, Soprano Liesl Odenweller, Flower Maiden IV, Soprano Liesl Odenweller, Squire I, Soprano Liesl Odenweller, Flower Maiden IV, Soprano Liesl Odenweller, Flower Maiden IV, Soprano Liesl Odenweller, Squire I, Soprano Matthias Hölle, Gurnemanz, Bass Mikolaj Zalasinski, Klingsor, Bass Ragnhild Kristina Motzfeldt, Flower Maiden V, Soprano Richard Decker, Parsifal, Tenor Richard Wagner, Composer Roberto Covatta, Squire III, Tenor Sara Allegretta, Flower Maiden III, Soprano Ulrich Dünnebach, Titurel, Bass Venice La Fenice Chorus Venice La Fenice Orchestra Voices of Little Venice Wolfgang Schöne, Amfortas, Baritone |
Author: Arnold Whittall
Productions of Parsifal with no forest and no Grail temple are par for today’s course but can be particularly alienating on DVD. At least the director of this production manages effective use of his singing actors from time to time – as when Gurnemanz sinks to the ground to kiss the earth (or rather, the wooden platform) at the end of the Good Friday scene. The dying swan, so often a problem for directors, is also well carried off (literally) here. But all too often we are shown sparing gestures, like Kundry’s non-washing of Parsifal’s feet, in inappropriate close-up.
Metal screens appear behind the central platform – what looks like corrugated iron for the Grail temple, something shinier for Klingsor’s garden. There is also a wooden cross-shaped object, placed behind three lumps of pale rock which serve as altar in the Grail scenes, otherwise as seats. The grail itself appears, the unveiling effectively done, though the empty glass we are shown in close-up is rather lacking in mystical power. Nevertheless, the dramatic force of the production gains considerably from good handling of the chorus, and from a flowermaidens scene, without embarrassing balletics, that features a group of nude figures in addition to the six singers.
The recorded sound is good, the orchestra well placed in relation to the singers, even though the shots we’re given only show strings, timpani and, on one occasion, bassoons. The all-important brass and upper woodwind are invisible but fortunately not inaudible. Conductor Gabor Ötvös sets suitably flowing tempi but his occasional broadenings are over-emphatic and cause the singers some fleeting discomfort.
The singers are an able team, while conveying a certain air of routine in what, in most cases, are seasoned interpretations. As Kundry, the veteran Doris Soffel often pushes very hard, though to considerable effect for most of Act 2, and while Wolfgang Schöne looks rather too old for Amfortas, he doesn’t sound it. Richard Decker is a personable Parsifal, though rather too inclined to stand and deliver when more nuance and even understatement are called for. Matthias Hölle is the mellifluous Gurnemanz, less well focused in the upper register than on the 1989 Barenboim CDs but still an imposing presence. By no means a wash-out, then: but the field remains open for a visually satisfying Parsifal on DVD.
Metal screens appear behind the central platform – what looks like corrugated iron for the Grail temple, something shinier for Klingsor’s garden. There is also a wooden cross-shaped object, placed behind three lumps of pale rock which serve as altar in the Grail scenes, otherwise as seats. The grail itself appears, the unveiling effectively done, though the empty glass we are shown in close-up is rather lacking in mystical power. Nevertheless, the dramatic force of the production gains considerably from good handling of the chorus, and from a flowermaidens scene, without embarrassing balletics, that features a group of nude figures in addition to the six singers.
The recorded sound is good, the orchestra well placed in relation to the singers, even though the shots we’re given only show strings, timpani and, on one occasion, bassoons. The all-important brass and upper woodwind are invisible but fortunately not inaudible. Conductor Gabor Ötvös sets suitably flowing tempi but his occasional broadenings are over-emphatic and cause the singers some fleeting discomfort.
The singers are an able team, while conveying a certain air of routine in what, in most cases, are seasoned interpretations. As Kundry, the veteran Doris Soffel often pushes very hard, though to considerable effect for most of Act 2, and while Wolfgang Schöne looks rather too old for Amfortas, he doesn’t sound it. Richard Decker is a personable Parsifal, though rather too inclined to stand and deliver when more nuance and even understatement are called for. Matthias Hölle is the mellifluous Gurnemanz, less well focused in the upper register than on the 1989 Barenboim CDs but still an imposing presence. By no means a wash-out, then: but the field remains open for a visually satisfying Parsifal on DVD.
Discover the world's largest classical music catalogue with Presto Music.

Gramophone Digital Club
- Digital Edition
- Digital Archive
- Reviews Database
- Full website access
From £8.75 / month
Subscribe
Gramophone Full Club
- Print Edition
- Digital Edition
- Digital Archive
- Reviews Database
- Full website access
From £11.00 / month
Subscribe
If you are a library, university or other organisation that would be interested in an institutional subscription to Gramophone please click here for further information.